The Kingdom of the Emerald Hills

I would like to see a written policy about what is to be moderated and when. Recently I think the moderators are making value judgements for the kingdom at large.

http://www.amtgard-eh.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=442
It has been there for a year. If you have any questions or concerns about a specific incident please PM me or Martello( However, Martello may take a long while to respond.)

_________________

Exactly what I was hoping to see. Please cite to me which part of this policy Fenris' initial post violated. Bear in mind none of the activities suggested were illegal (on a federal level), merely not suitable for us and a disclaimer was made to check your local laws at the beginning of the post.

Also, this discussion will be held in public, since you are the person whose behavior is in question.

On the topic of citing rules:
"Do not create another thread asking why a post was deleted, or a thread was locked. If you believe your post was deleted in error PM an Admin. "

Which Fenris has done, and she is very capable of arguing her own case. My conversation with her (and with Martello) is ongoing, and a final decision has not yet been reached.

_________________

Elder: Your suggestion that I should refrain from questioning your inappropriate actions is absurd.

Again I'm asking you to cite the portion of the admin policy violated by Fenris with her initial post.

Just to be clear I am not asking you to attempt to quash a reasonable request by hiding behind policies you refuse to follow when they are not convenient to you.

Any follow up on this?

_________________
Forest Evergreen

Puppet Master of the EH

"Of course you are Forest. You're like the Mr. Burns of EH." - Finn

(insert titles and awards here)

I think the follow up is "Elder is a coward" followed by "Elder broke the rules".

I'm proposing "Lets remove Elder from positions of responsibility" as a solution.

Elder might have been following orders...he might not have. BUT the person who wanted my post gone was Dreanya. Im a strong advocate of don't kill the messenger...kill the source of the problem. Of course im saying this figuratively ! But at the same time acknowledging there is a problem.

Fenris

_________________
“All in all, it comes down to us as a society to embrace and encourage the values we wish to see demonstrated within our club.” - Kurse

"One People, One Planet"
haven-int.org
spirit-chronicles.org

In all fairness, there were a lot of people that wanted your drivel removed. The fault lies with the lacky that did so.

Sparhawk

To set the record straight: I did not tell Elder to remove any posts. On the contrary, I advised that if anything must be moved, that it be moved to the Smack Talk Forum.

_________________

The plot thickens ::duh duh duh::

_________________
“All in all, it comes down to us as a society to embrace and encourage the values we wish to see demonstrated within our club.” - Kurse

"One People, One Planet"
haven-int.org
spirit-chronicles.org

Let me amend my previous statement:
The follow up is "Elder is a lying coward" followed by "Elder broke the rules."

I'm still suggesting "remove Elder from positions of responsibility" as a solution.

There has been no follow up because there is nothing to follow up on. I publicly stated my reasons for moving fenris's thread at the time I did it, and no one has PM'd me or Martello for further discussion other than Dreanya and Fenris, both of whom I believe I resolved their questions. As no one else has PM'd me or Martello, I can assume that no one else has any real concerns about it.

Since it has been brought up in this thread I will publicly state that the decision to move the thread was mine alone, and I was not asked to move the thread.

No one will be rewarded for breaking forum rules by getting what they want.

There will not be a public discussion.

This thread will now be locked as per Martello's request.

As has been stated previously if anyone has any concerns they may PM me to discuss them privately, or if for whatever reason you do not wish to PM me you may PM Martello to discuss it as well.

_________________